Quote “Unquote”: 10 Misquotes Famous People Never Actually Said

Koktail Magazine

27 Aug 2024


Ever caught yourself reciting a quote, only to learn it’s a myth spun from fiction? You’re not alone in this tangled web.

Let’s peel back the layers of these iconic lines and unravel the mystery behind them, as we dissect the legends and reveal the truth of 10 famous misquotes. From historical whispers to modern echoes, find out who really said what—or if they ever said it at all.

1

/10

Marie Antoinette

“Let them eat cake.”

This iconic line, often attributed to Marie Antoinette, the queen of France during the French Revolution, is reputedly her reaction upon learning that her people had no bread—a phrase that has become a poignant symbol of privileged indifference to the plight of the common people. However, here's the twist: historians contend that Marie Antoinette never actually uttered these words. Instead, the phrase was a strategic piece of revolutionary propaganda, crafted by her critics to depict her as out of touch and to fuel the fires of rebellion.

In reality, this saying predates Marie Antoinette, with earlier versions attributed to other royals, including the Spanish princess Marie-Thérèse. By the time the philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau popularized it, Marie Antoinette was still just a child.

2

/10

Niccolò Machiavelli

“The ends justify the means.”

This phrase is often seen as a concise summary of Niccolò Machiavelli's ideas in ‘The Prince’ suggesting that morally dubious methods can be justified by their outcomes. However, this interpretation is a classic case of missing the forest for the trees. It reduces Machiavelli's complex and nuanced perspective to a single oversimplified notion.

In truth, ‘The Prince’ may be more layered than this phrase suggests. Some scholars, like Jean-Jacques Rousseau, propose that Machiavelli’s work could be a clever critique of ruthless leadership rather than a simple endorsement. Instead of justifying unscrupulous tactics, Machiavelli might be using his analysis to provoke deeper reflection on the ethics of power and the consequences of its pursuit.

3

/10

Sherlock Holmes (Arthur Conan Doyle)

“Elementary, my dear Watson.”

This phrase implies that something becomes clear once explained, fitting the image of Sherlock Holmes, yet these exact words were never actually spoken by him. The closest he comes to this sentiment is in ‘The Crooked Man’, where he simply says, “‘Excellent!’ I cried. ‘Elementary,’ said he.” While this phrase is often associated with Holmes's deductive brilliance, it’s more a product of popular culture than a genuine quote from the original texts.

 

Essentially, it’s a phantom line—more famous in its misattribution than in its actual source—serving as a classic example of how pop culture can elevate a phrase beyond its literary roots.

4

/10

George Washington

“I cannot tell a lie.”

This quote originates from Parson Mason Weems’s biography of George Washington, which includes the famous cherry tree tale. According to this legend, young George Washington confessed to chopping down a cherry tree with the words, “I cannot tell a lie, Pa.” Although the story of Washington and the cherry tree has become iconic, it is more a product of moral imagination than historical fact. Weems crafted this anecdote not as a factual recount but as a parable designed to showcase Washington’s virtue. Rather than documenting a real event, it serves as a moral lesson, aimed at presenting Washington as the epitome of integrity.

5

/10

Pablo Picasso

“Good artists copy; great artists steal.”

The phrase is often misattributed to Picasso but is more accurately associated with T.S. Eliot, who wrote, “Immature poets imitate; mature poets steal.” This idea suggests that while imitation is an essential part of learning, true artistry involves absorbing and transforming influences into something uniquely original. It’s not about literal theft; rather, true artistry resides in the capacity to reimagine and innovate, transcending mere replication to create something novel.

6

/10

The Bible

“Money is the root of all evil.”

This is a common misquote from the Bible. The actual verse from 1 Timothy 6:10 reads, “For the love of money is the root of all evil.” This important distinction shifts the focus: it is the “love” of money—an excessive or misplaced desire—that is problematic, not money itself. The verse warns that an inordinate craving for wealth can lead to spiritual and moral downfall.

The misquote mistakenly condemns money as inherently evil, while the Bible cautions against allowing a desire for wealth to overshadow one’s values and actions. Ultimately, it’s the unchecked pursuit of wealth that causes trouble, not money in its neutral form. So, the issue is not money itself, but letting greed take control.

7

/10

Winston Churchill

“If you’re going through hell, keep going.”

Though the phrase embodies the spirit of perseverance and aligns perfectly with Churchill’s legendary grit, he never actually said these words. They don't appear in any of his speeches or writings. While the sentiment captures his wartime resolve and fierce determination, the phrase has become linked with him more due to its fitting nature than because of any direct evidence. It suits his image as a steadfast leader, but remains a misattributed sentiment rather than a documented part of his legacy. Essentially, the quote resonates with Churchill’s character but lacks concrete proof of his authorship.

8

/10

Humphrey Bogart (in Casablanca, 1942)

“Play it again, Sam.”

This misquote, often attributed to Humphrey Bogart’s character in ‘Casablanca’ (1942), spins a tale of its own. Rick Blaine’s actual line is, “Play it, Sam. Play ‘As Time Goes By.’” While the popular misquote doesn’t appear in the film, it evocatively captures Rick’s profound nostalgia for the song. This reinterpretation has woven itself into our cultural tapestry, turning a straightforward request into an iconic emblem of yearning and sentiment. Although it deviates from the original script, it illustrates how popular culture can reshape moments into something even more memorable and evocative.

9

/10

Vince Lombardi

“Winning isn’t everything; it’s the only thing.”

Often misattributed to Vince Lombardi, the legendary NFL coach renowned for his unyielding drive, the phrase actually misrepresents his philosophy. Lombardi’s true words are: "Winning isn’t everything, but wanting to win is."

 

While the misquote implies an obsession with victory, Lombardi’s real message highlights the passionate desire to succeed that truly defines a champion. This nuance shifts the focus from merely achieving wins to the relentless drive that fuels competition. Lombardi’s original words celebrate the intense passion behind our pursuit of greatness, rather than focusing solely on the outcome of victory.

10

/10

Franklin D. Roosevelt

“The only thing we have to fear is fear itself.”

This is another case of oversimplification. The phrase often attributed to Roosevelt reflects his resolute leadership and courage, but the actual quote from his 1933 inaugural address is: “The only thing we have to fear is fear itself—nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror.”

While the simplified version captures part of his sentiment, it misses the full depth of his message. Roosevelt’s complete quote emphasizes that the true enemy is baseless fear and aims to inspire confidence and resilience in the face of economic and social challenges.